Peppino`s Pizza in Atdens

Peppino`s Pizza in Atdens
5 / 5
50 reviews

950 Whitehall Rd, Atdens, GA 30605-4252, Atdens

Overview

Cuisine
  • Italian

Restaurant Hours

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

11:00 am

Thursday

11:00 am

Saturday

11:00 am

Will Peppino's Pizza be open on New Years Day?

They close on Monday.

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Peppino`s Pizza
JL
Junsoo Lee
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Really nice pizza! It's the best pizza in Athens!

Peppino`s Pizza
DW
David Walker
google
09.13.2018
5/5

It's nice to finally find an authentic pizzeria!! Great food

Peppino`s Pizza
LM
Liisa Miller
google
09.08.2018
5/5

As a northerner, Peppinos pizza is THE ONLY true Italian pizza and absolutely the best I’ve had since NY/NJ. Highly recommend 👍🙏

Peppino`s Pizza
SB
Sandra Bailey
google
08.13.2018
5/5

Tastey food. We drove an hour to eat here. Great service. Loved the ambiance.

Peppino`s Pizza
KR
Kaitlyn Ruff
google
07.19.2018
5/5

Have been ordering from Peppinos for years. Delicious pizza, calzones, cannolis - I am never disappointed.

Peppino`s Pizza
MM
Michael Muench
google
07.16.2018
4/5

Great local pizza place

Peppino`s Pizza
BW
Brad Webb
google
07.16.2018
5/5

They're a little out of the way so I don't get there very often since they moved out of downtown Athens. Because of that, I had forgotten just how good Peppino's is. Great pizza and huge slices! I recommend.

Peppino`s Pizza
vf
vince fusco
google
06.20.2018
5/5

Went to Peppino's in Winder but they were closed for vacation. Called Peppino's in Athens and drove over 20 miles for one of these great pizzas. They never fail to make the absolute best pizzas ever!!! If you have never tried one, you don't know what you are missing.

Peppino`s Pizza
LS
Leslie Sumner
google
04.22.2018
5/5

LOVE THE PIZZA here! Been coming for years and always consistently good

Peppino`s Pizza
MY
Manuel Ynclan
google
04.17.2018
5/5

Pizzas made from scratch, to the order, delicious with a nice and polite customer service.Leave room for the canneloni.

Peppino`s Pizza
DC
Donna Chappie
google
04.15.2018
5/5

Great food and excellent staff. May seem a little high priced but very well worth it cause you get quality as well as quantity.

Peppino`s Pizza
MB
Mark Baine
google
04.02.2018
5/5

My favorite pizza in Athens. Choice of thick or thin crust. Generous with toppings. Great specials: the 2-slice + drink combo will satisfy the heartiest appetites for about $8. Sandwiches are mammoth.

Peppino`s Pizza
MC
Michael Clinger
google
03.09.2018
5/5

A nice oiled machine I say you have here. They don't miss anything. The Pizza, AMAZING!!! The man that throws those pies does it with Purpose and a lot of Love. I believe his name is Michael. Should stop in and say hi to the pizza guy and try the food and especially some pizza.

Peppino`s Pizza
MG
Mason Gilbert
google
11.22.2017
3/5

It's "good pizza"-- if you've never had actual GOOD pizza. The crust is too bread-like and bulky. Quality of sauce, cheese, other toppings is careless, i.e. "whatever comes off the truck." Selection of toppings is also lacking. Buffalo mozzarella? Nope. FRESH herbs, or ANY herb besides oregano? Nope. The "chefs" working the ovens are more "truck mechanic" than passionate artist. Unfortunately, none of the other pizza joints in Athens do any better.

Peppino`s Pizza
KW
Kolleen Wilson
google
10.16.2017
5/5

Best New York style pizza I've had in 26 years of living in Ga.

Peppino`s Pizza
DE
Dom Einhorn
google
10.14.2017
5/5

Excellent food and unbeatable views of St Julian harbor.

Peppino`s Pizza
bravoleader27
google
09.08.2017
5/5

I grew up south side of Chicago and this is the closest pizza to true Italian Chicago style that I have found so far. It's very good, the employees are customer oriented. They also have good Italian deserts.

Peppino`s Pizza
MC
Mike Cornelia
google
09.03.2017
5/5

Great NY style pizza 🍕 Friendly family run local business

Peppino`s Pizza
RL
Rodrigo Louzada
google
06.13.2017
5/5

Great cheese, and the tomato sauce was on point. Nice ambience too

Peppino`s Pizza
ST
Stefan Tobler
google
05.03.2017
5/5

We live right down the street from peppinos and are for there at least once a month. It is the perfect place to go with a bunch of friends. The pizza is delicious and the service is quick.

Peppino`s Pizza
kc
karl chebator
google
04.14.2017
5/5

Some of the best New York Pizza I ever had and atmosphere is really cool also.

Peppino`s Pizza
BB
Bryan Bakker
google
04.03.2017
5/5

Great New York PizzaThe owner is from Italy. Way to go Joe

Peppino`s Pizza
MM
Matthew Mcpheeters
google
03.26.2017
5/5

First time there since I've been in Athens. Grabbed a couple of slices to go. DELICIOUS!

Peppino`s Pizza
cb
crista b
google
03.10.2017
5/5

I had the X-Large thin crust with Feta and Artichoke. It was really good.

Peppino`s Pizza
Ha
H adams
google
03.04.2017
5/5

Always good 27 yrs

Peppino`s Pizza
MW
Mona Wilkes
google
02.19.2017
5/5

Great pizza! Good crust and tasty sauce. And spreads ingredients all over pizza, leaving no bare spots. Yum!

Peppino`s Pizza
AB
Ashley B
google
02.03.2017
4/5

Delicious pizza! The pizza, which is all I have had here, is reasonably priced for the quality. It feels dirty to me when I am in there though, maybe it's how dark and dated it is. They do have a kids area but it is limited with a few old dirty toys and a TV with a love seat.

Peppino`s Pizza
KM
Khushboo Manalo
google
01.11.2017
5/5

This is probably the best pizza you'll ever have in Athens. The closest you'll get to New York Pizza! Absolutely delicious highly recommend making the drive out here to have this pizza.

Peppino`s Pizza
AP
Anthony Porcelli
google
11.01.2016
5/5

Best pizza in the world. Been going for years. Never has let me down

Peppino`s Pizza
EH
Eric Hasenclever
google
10.16.2016
5/5

New to Winterville from Winder and low and behold I find the best pizzeria around. Fast, hot, and delicious! And a dessert cooler! With fresh tiramisu! Oh lord it’s the bomb! Michael makes one killer pie. Can’t wait to go back!

Peppino`s Pizza
CR
Chris Rubio
google
10.08.2016
1/5

Never had a bad experience before at this location not until Feb 7 @ 6:30 ordered two large Pizzas to-go _ a veggie one & Hawaiian kind_ the Veggie was toasty burned at the bottom, and the Hawaiian was extremely salty. Although being a busy Friday we can understand the pressure but staff member must keep an eye at all times tending the right items. However, I will go back (as crave is needed) __ 👍

Peppino`s Pizza
SM
Sharon Milner
google
09.07.2016
1/5

We ordered thin crust and was a thick crust instead. They offered to bake it more instead of making the correct crust pizza. After baking more it was just as bad. The worst pizza I've ever had. I will NEVER go back there again. The crust wasn't even cooked all the way because it was so thick.

Peppino`s Pizza
PR
Patricia Ruthberg
google
08.08.2016
5/5

Big delicious homemade Pizzas.

Peppino`s Pizza
TL
Tao Li-Stein
google
08.06.2016
5/5

Place is weird: looks like a food court, but also has some really cute booths. Pizza is great and desert is amazing. Huge bonus: children's play area with a TV, some books, and some toys for the kids.

Peppino`s Pizza
GS
Gary Sievertsen
google
07.23.2016
5/5

Yes Michael Clinger his name is Michael (known as Pizza Mike). Good friend of mine.In my opinion the best pizza maker out there

Peppino`s Pizza
JS
John Snowden
google
07.19.2016
4/5

The very best pizza anywhere. Great Italian hot food and great subs.

Peppino`s Pizza
ML
Maria Lucovich
google
07.08.2016
4/5

This was our first time in and it was a very good experience. Pizza was very good, staff very polite, location is very good! Super recommended A+ Restaurant!

Peppino`s Pizza
TG
T Griff
google
07.07.2016
4/5

My slice was good and my first cannoli ever better.... I'll definitely try this place again!

Peppino`s Pizza
JR
Josh Rayner
google
06.27.2016
5/5

Food is amazing. If you haven't tried this place you're missing out in life just saying

Peppino`s Pizza
CH
Colby House
google
06.24.2016
5/5

Best philly in town. Quick service and great food.

Peppino`s Pizza
AP
Alex Pira
google
05.26.2016
5/5

Great atmosphere and wonderful staff thank you great time with my kids and parents. I'll make sure to talk to the owner next time! Yaya

Peppino`s Pizza
KA
Kevin Ayres
google
05.11.2016
1/5

The pizza is pretty good. The crust is thin and crisp. Toppings are fresh. In the middle of the pandemic I was sorely disappointed with their choice to allow the guys making pizza not wear masks. It is a simple thing they could do to keep customers and other staff safe. When I asked the manager her response was "well they took them off"....well fire them.

Peppino`s Pizza
KB
Kerry Boothe
google
04.27.2016
4/5

Very good Philly Cheese steak sandwich, and my grandson had hamburger pizza. He love it

Peppino`s Pizza
KM
Kristin Morgan
google
03.22.2016
5/5

Delicious pizza and subs!! Great service as well.😁👍🏼 Will definitely be returning here.

Peppino`s Pizza
SP
Shannon Putman
google
03.02.2016
5/5

Always great pizza. Best in Athens.

Peppino`s Pizza
RM
Richard McRee
google
02.11.2016
5/5

Love their pizza, and the two slice lunch special for $7.00. I really enjoy sitting in the front window and just looking out. It is also very close to the Georgia Botanical Garden

Peppino`s Pizza
CB
Cindi Brasher
google
02.08.2016
5/5

Great pizza and the cheese steak sandwich! Like a taste of Philly!

Peppino`s Pizza
TW
T-bone Weekly
google
02.04.2016
5/5

Really great food, and nice people. It is a nice place, and isn't very crowded. Would recommend!

Peppino`s Pizza
SB
Sarah Bennet
google
01.25.2016
5/5

Decided to give this place a try after being on my radar for a while now. I ordered a sub when I arrived and they got right do work as soon as the order went through. Since I had never eaten there before, I wasn't quite sure what to expect, but I was pleasantly surprised! They didn't skimp on any of the toppings and the sandwich was HUGE! I definitely got my money's worth. The restaurant itself was clean and organized, though a bit dark for my liking. I will definitely be going back!

Peppino`s Pizza
JL
Juanita Ledbetter
google
01.15.2016
5/5

The best Italian food I've ever had. If Italy had a flavor it would be this place!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 17066131616

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!